When Children Need Hearing Aids How Jake’s Mom Took on an Insurance Company-and Won Features
Features  |   September 01, 2006
When Children Need Hearing Aids
Author Notes
  • Dee Naquin Shafer, an assistant managing editor of The ASHA Leader, can be reached at dshafer@asha.org.
    Dee Naquin Shafer, an assistant managing editor of The ASHA Leader, can be reached at dshafer@asha.org.×
Article Information
Hearing Aids, Cochlear Implants & Assistive Technology / Special Populations / Early Identification & Intervention / Features
Features   |   September 01, 2006
When Children Need Hearing Aids
The ASHA Leader, September 2006, Vol. 11, 5-23. doi:10.1044/leader.FTR2.11122006.5
The ASHA Leader, September 2006, Vol. 11, 5-23. doi:10.1044/leader.FTR2.11122006.5
Jake Mackey was three years old before he began talking, says his mom, Angel Mackey. But it didn’t seem anything to be concerned about at the time. The pediatrician told her that often children with older siblings don’t talk early.
“I was thinking about taking him for a hearing test and then a week or two later, he started exploding with talk, so I didn’t follow up,” she said. When Jake was born in 1999, his home state of Maryland did not require hearing screening for all newborns.
Angel Mackey challenged an insurance company to pay for hearing aids for her then 5-year-old son, Jake.
He completed pre-kindergarten before his first hearing test. Although he failed it, the school nurse chalked this up to his being so young.
But after Jake failed several other hearing tests, Mackey brought him to Dupont Hospital in Wilmington, DE. An audiologist there found that Jake had a moderate sensorineural hearing loss. It turned out that he was making up for problems in communicating by lip-reading.
“I used to think it was strange that Jake would sleep a lot, even with lots of noise in the house. I would think, he’s such a good baby,” she said.
Testing revealed Jake’s hearing loss as genetic. Mackey is missing the same gene, but her hearing loss is mild. She plans to take her older son, Alex, age 14, for genetic testing this year.
“It caught me off guard when the audiologist started talking about hearing aids,” Mackey said. She was even more surprised after calling the insurance company and learning that neither hearing aids nor tests were covered.
“The more I thought about it, the more it seemed ridiculous. (Insurance) pays to have a lot of other things done,” Mackey said. She began researching the issue, located ASHA’s Web site, and found some answers to advocate for Jake.
Making an Exception
“I printed out tons of information from ASHA’s Web site that pertained to his hearing loss,” she said. A conversation with an ASHA staff member followed. “She sent me information along with some ideas to remember when you talk to your insurance company,” Mackey said.
Mackey put together a letter using information from ASHA and from her employer’s research plan. She noted that the insurance would pay for expensive procedures such as in vitro fertilization for at least two attempts, as well as for vasectomies and breast reduction surgeries.
“I said that while these are all important, my son’s need to hear well is no less important,” she recalled. Mackey pointed out that at five years of age, Jake was at an important stage in learning where information would begin to come very quickly. He would begin to develop some independence. Now 7, he is doing well in school.
“My husband and I are nurses and we could have worked overtime to cover the hearing aids, but it bothered me that the hearing of a 5-year-old child wasn’t considered important,” she said. The insurance company made an exception in its policy for Jake’s case and decided to pay for his hearing aids.
“If somebody else were to come with a similar situation, they would take it on a case-by-case basis,” she said. “I’ve been told that most insurance companies don’t pay for hearing aids. But that doesn’t mean you have to go along with it.”
Newborn Hearing Screening

Currently, 45 states and the District of Columbia have Early Hearing Detection and Intervention (EHDI) laws or voluntary compliance programs that screen the hearing of 95% or more of newborns. Forty states have laws and five states have voluntary programs.

ASHA led the fight for EHDI and is focusing on the need at both the state and federal levels to enact legislation that promotes evaluation and intervention after hearing screening for newborns and infants. Although more than 90% of all newborns are now screened for hearing loss before leaving the hospital, many still do not receive needed follow-up services. Only about one-half of the babies referred from newborn hearing screening programs receive diagnostic evaluations by three months of age. Moreover, only about half of those diagnosed with hearing loss are enrolled in early intervention programs by six months of age.

For information about advocacy, visit ASHA’s Legislation & Advocacy Web page or contact Jim Potter (federal legislation) at jpotter@asha.org. This is one of the last articles that Charlie Diggs, ASHA’s director of consumer advocacy, reviewed before his untimely passing on July 31. Diggs made significant contributions to EHDI legislation.

Submit a Comment
Submit A Comment
Comment Title

This feature is available to Subscribers Only
Sign In or Create an Account ×
September 2006
Volume 11, Issue 12